Skip to content
Snippets Groups Projects
Closed (moved) Research: Does N23 help especially much in cases where the first hop is slow/flaky?
  • View options
  • Research: Does N23 help especially much in cases where the first hop is slow/flaky?

  • View options
  • Closed (moved) Issue created by Roger Dingledine

    Once upon a time I thought that using Tor on a modem shouldn't be that bad -- the modem is bad, and the Tor network is bad, but the combination of them should be dominated by whichever is worse.

    Tor turns out to not work that way in practice: composing a bad first link with a bad Tor network yields a way worse experience than can be explained by either component by itself.

    My hypothesis is that this crummy experience is due to the same issue that N23 aims to address: the fact that our end-to-end flow control needs cells to make it through an entire round trip before more cells are sent.

    We should explore N23 simulations in the case where Alice's connection to her first hop is flaky (where flaky might be some combination of low bandwidth, high latency, and non-trivial packet loss), and for various loads on the Tor network side.

    Oh, and we should probably get some control runs where we do the simulations with vanilla Tor rather than Tor+N23.

    Linked items ... 0

  • Activity

    • All activity
    • Comments only
    • History only
    • Newest first
    • Oldest first
    Loading Loading Loading Loading Loading Loading Loading Loading Loading Loading