|Reported by:||arma||Owned by:|
|Keywords:||Cc:||sebastian, aagbsn, karsten, dkantola@…, gordon@…, Lunar|
|Actual Points:||Parent ID:|
The monolithic design of check.tp.o has given us grief for years. Here's my grand vision for the redesigned future of check and related components:
A) A component that discovers the 'real' outgoing IP addresses of exits, and outputs a file like
https://exitlist.torproject.org/exit-addresses from them.
That component could start out being tordnsel. It could later be TorBEL if somebody fixes it. Or it could later be a simple script to parse the @source annotations in directory authority cached-descriptor files, drop instances where the source is another directory authority, and if we want to get fancy, aggregate results from several directory authorities.
Note that there's no reason to run this component as or near any user-facing service: it just needs to somehow export the static file periodically so others can get it.
B) A script that takes in this exit-addresses script, a Tor consensus document, and a destination port, and outputs a list of exit IPs that allow connections to that port.
This is similar to Nick's 'exitlist' script from back in the day (you can still find it in contrib/exitlist in the Tor git), except it 1) incorporates the active exit addresses, 2) doesn't look at the whole exit policy in the descriptors, since clients don't either (I'm amenable to changing this part if people want), and 3) considers whether relays are Running (since only running relays are in the consensus).
For users who want to consider all relays in the past n hours, this script should be able to handle reading multiple consensus files (ideally just by concatenating them before they go in).
C) Some recommended glue code that takes in the output of 'B' and a test IP address, and tells you if the test IP address is in the list. In most languages I expect this will be short and sweet.
D) A user-facing web service called check.torproject.org that runs the code from 'C' to tell users if they seem to be coming from a Tor exit. To be clear, the job of the check cgi is to read a static text file and tell you if your IP address is in it.
E) A user-facing web service called bulkexitlist that runs the code from 'B'. That is, it inputs the exit-addresses file, the consensus(es), and your destination port, and outputs a static text file of IPs that will exit to you. This wants to run in a separate place from check.tp.o, and maybe we won't even be the ones to run it.
Change History (32)
comment:30 Changed 17 months ago by arlolra
- Resolution set to implemented
- Status changed from new to closed